How Companies Decide Salary (It’s Not What You Think)
⏱ Reading time: 6 minutes
Hello Reader,
Welcome to On HR's Radar, my weekly newsletter where I give actionable job search, Career & leadership insights from my experience as Career Coach & founder of Executive Search business Perennial HR
If you're looking for my Cheat Sheet PDFs, the link is at the bottom of this email!
How Companies Decide Salary (It’s Not What You Think)
Reading time: 6 minutes
🔑 Key Takeaways
- Salary is tied to the role, not the individual
- Market data and salary bands set strict boundaries
- Internal equity often limits how high offers can go
- Your past salary can anchor your future earnings
- Business impact, not experience alone, drives higher offers
How Companies Really Decide Salary
Only 46% of professionals negotiate their salary, yet the bigger issue is this: most don’t understand how salaries are decided in the first place.
Compensation decisions are structured, data driven, and largely predefined. If you don’t understand the system, you can’t influence it.
Salary Isn’t About You. It’s About the Role
One of the biggest misconceptions is that salary reflects your experience. It doesn’t. It reflects the value of the role to the business.
Before a job is posted, companies define a salary range based on:
- Scope and responsibilities
- Expected impact
- Level within the organisation
This means:
- Two candidates with different backgrounds can receive similar offers
- Your negotiation happens within a fixed range, not outside it
Hiring managers aren’t asking, “What are you worth?”
They’re asking, “What is this role worth to us?”
Market Data and Salary Bands Control the Offer
Companies don’t guess salaries. They benchmark against the market.
This creates structured salary bands with:
These bands exist to:
- Stay competitive
- Maintain cost control
When companies say they’re “open on salary,” they usually mean within a range, not unlimited flexibility.
Negotiation has limits because you’re operating inside an existing system.
Internal Equity: The Hidden Constraint
Your salary isn’t just about you. It’s about everyone already in the company.
Internal equity ensures:
- Fairness across similar roles
- Consistency in pay structures
If companies overpay new hires, they risk:
- Pay dissatisfaction
- Retention issues
- Internal conflict
This creates a natural ceiling, even for strong candidates.
Sometimes, a lower than expected offer isn’t about your value. It’s about maintaining balance across the team.
Why Your Last Salary Still Matters
Many companies still anchor offers to your previous salary, often adding 10% to 20%.
From their perspective, this ensures:
- Logical career progression
- Alignment with internal structures
But here’s the problem:
Your past salary may not reflect your current market value.
This is how candidates stay underpaid. A low previous salary can cap future earnings, even when the new role is worth more.
The shift you need to make:
- Stop focusing on “What was I paid?”
- Start focusing on “What is this role worth, and what value do I bring?”
Candidates who make this shift are more likely to break out of percentage based increases.
Interview Performance Determines Your Position
Salary bands set the range.
Your interview performance decides where you land.
The biggest differentiator is evidence of business impact.
Strong candidates:
- Quantify results with numbers
- Link experience to current business problems
- Show they’ve solved similar challenges before
Compare this:
“I improved onboarding”
vs
“I redesigned onboarding, reducing ramp up time by 30% and saving $250,000 annually”
The second example signals:
- Commercial awareness
- Execution ability
- Lower hiring risk
And lower risk leads to higher offers.
Budget and Business Priorities Set the Ceiling
Even the best candidate faces a limit. That limit is budget.
Every role is tied to:
- Headcount costs
- Department budgets
- Revenue forecasts
- Hiring urgency
This affects offers more than most candidates realise.
- High urgency roles often stretch toward the top
- Lower priority roles stay near the midpoint
Your value doesn’t change, but the company’s ability to pay does.
When Companies Go Beyond the Salary Band
There are exceptions. Companies will stretch when there’s a clear business case.
1. New, High Impact Roles
New roles often lack fixed benchmarks.
If you can show you will:
- Save money, or
- Generate revenue
The conversation shifts from cost to investment.
2. Transformation or Change
During periods of change, companies lack critical skills.
If you’ve:
- Led similar transformations
- Delivered results quickly
They are more willing to pay above the band to reduce risk and delay.
What Actually Works in Negotiation
Negotiation doesn’t start at the offer stage.
It’s the result of everything that came before.
By the time you get an offer, the company has already decided:
- Where you sit in the range
- How much risk you represent
The candidates who secure stronger offers:
- Prove impact early
- Use data, not opinions
- Position themselves as solutions
How to Position Yourself for a Higher Salary
If you want better offers, focus on what actually moves the needle:
- Show measurable results, not responsibilities
- Build credibility early in the process
- Align your experience with business outcomes
High performing candidates don’t rely on applications alone.
They position themselves strategically.
Conclusion
Salary decisions are structured, not personal. They are driven by market data, internal equity, and business priorities.
But candidates who consistently secure higher offers do three things well:
- They demonstrate measurable impact
- They shift the conversation away from past salary
- They position themselves as an investment, not a cost
If you let your previous salary define you, you stay anchored.
If you prove your value in business terms, you expand what’s possible.
If you’re looking to improve your approach, you might find these helpful: How to Increase Your Interviews in 30 Days, 6 Most Common CV Mistakes to Avoid,and The 7 Psychology Biases in Interviews (And How to Use Them in Your Favour) Each offers practical, candidate focused advice to help you stand out, strengthen your positioning, and ultimately secure stronger offers
Cheat Sheets
Click on the button below to get access to all our Hi res Cheat Sheets on
Career Advice, Hiring Advice, HR Insights and Leadership
|